Roxon’s data retention scheme worse than Australia card

“Attorney-General Nicola Roxon’s proposal to force internet service providers to log details of every Australian’s internet usage is one of the most significant threats to individual liberty in Australian history,” said Simon Breheny, director of the Rule of Law Project at the free market think tank the Institute of Public Affairs.

Mr Breheny and Chris Berg, IPA Director of Policy, appeared before the Parliamentary Inquiry into National Security Reforms in Melbourne today.

“The proposal would be a rolling, systematic and excessive invasion of the privacy of all Australians, just in case they are in the future ever suspected of committing a crime. This would be a complete reversal of the presumption of innocence, a key element of the rule of law,” said Mr Breheny.

The IPA told the Inquiry that the privacy implications of the current proposals are strikingly similar to the national identity card proposal of the mid-1980s.

“The IPA was one of the most prominent opponents of the Australia card then, and we are proud to be a prominent opponent of Nicola Roxon’s data retention proposal now,” said Mr Breheny.

In 1986 the IPA wrote that “Australians should not allow themselves to be bullied into accepting a proposal which has ominous implications and particularly a grave temptation for abuse by government.”

Today, the IPA issued the same warning in response to the proposed data retention regime.

About Simon Breheny

Simon Breheny is Director of the Legal Rights Project at the Institute of Public Affairs. Simon has been published in the Australian, the Sydney Morning Herald, the Herald Sun, the Punch and the Canberra Times and is regularly interviewed on radio in relation to legal rights and rule of law issues. He also recently appeared before the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security to give evidence on the government’s contentious data retention proposal. Simon is currently completing a Bachelor of Arts/Bachelor of Laws at the University of Melbourne. While completing his studies, Simon was elected President of the Melbourne University Law Students’ Society and appointed Vice-President of the Victorian Council of Law Students’ Societies.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Let’s ban profit! : Hey… what did I miss? | Institute of Public Affairs - September 6, 2012

    [...] the IPA’s Chris Berg and Simon Breheny told the federal parliamentary inquiry into national security reforms it was bad and dangerous for the [...]