“Unreasonable”, “unjust”, “oppressive maladministration”: ICAC slammed in this latest report

David_Levine

Inspector of the ICAC, David Levine

ICAC Inspector David Levine issued a scathing review of the New South Wales anti-corruption watchdog, in a report tabled in NSW parliament today.

In particular, ICAC Commissioner Margaret Latham is taken to task for the Commission’s conduct surrounding the controversial investigation of Margaret Cunneen.

Frankly, it is fascinating reading. Here are just some of the quotes from the report:

… It is of concern that the Commissioner issued the Notices… “to attend and produce forthwith” [mobile phones already in ICAC’s possession] given that this in fact rendered them unlawful. This amounts to an abuse of power and serious maladministration. [Page 18]

… I did not yield to the Commissioner’s expectation, I am not subject to the Commission in any respect… [Page 23]

… I can only assume that the Commission at that time had a view that its “independence” was particularly fragile if just stating its obligations to keep the public informed of the steps it proposed to take…  was seen as threatening. [Page 34]

… I find the ICAC email to be insulting, condescending and to border on insolent and reinforces views I have late I have lately expressed as to the breathtaking arrogance of the Commission [Page 34]

… a total lack of understanding of the role of the Inspector… [Page 39]

… This aspect of the conduct of the ICAC I describe, and I believe any ordinary reasonable person would describe, as unreasonable, unjust and oppressive. [Page 51]

… it is another example of unreasonable, unjust, oppressive maladministration on the part of the ICAC. It was a last ditch stance of defiance and… reflects poorly on its standing and objectivity. It is an abuse of the powers reposed in it. [Page 56-7]

To read these quotes in context, read Levine’s report here. Or you can read more ICAC coverage on FreedomWatch here.

facebooktwitter

, , ,

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes